• About
    • Our Story
    • Coupe du Monde Award
    • Join Our Team
  • Bakery Items
    • Bakery Items
    • Behind The Scenes
  • Farmer’s Markets
  • Holidays & Specials
    • Pi Day
    • St. Joseph’s Day
    • St. Patrick’s Day
    • Easter
    • Passover
    • Mother’s Day
  • Order Online
    • Order for Pickup
    • From Our Bakery To Your Door
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Coupe du Monde Award
    • Join Our Team
  • Bakery Items
    • Bakery Items
    • Behind The Scenes
  • Farmer’s Markets
  • Holidays & Specials
    • Pi Day
    • St. Joseph’s Day
    • St. Patrick’s Day
    • Easter
    • Passover
    • Mother’s Day
  • Order Online
    • Order for Pickup
    • From Our Bakery To Your Door

Holidays & Specials

Galette des Rois

Bennison's Bakery offers Pithivier (or Galette des Rois). Layers of puff pastry filled with almond frangipane (a sweet almond paste), glazed with sugar and topped with a crown. Each Pithivier is baked with a tiny baby trinket inside, and tradition states that whoever finds the baby in their slice is supposed to bring the Pithivier the next year.

Order Online

King Cake

Order a brightly decorated King Cake—a traditional pre-Lenten treat perfect for Mardi Gras and the Epiphany season. Bennison’s offers them plain or filled with cream cheese, apple, cherry, or praline pecan.

Order Online

Valentine's Day

Bennison’s Bakery is celebrating Valentine’s Day with a delightful selection of holiday-themed sweets and treats available for pre-order or in-store pickup from February 1 through February 14. Whether you’re looking to surprise a sweetheart or share something special with friends and family, the bakery offers an array of heart-inspired creations, including beautifully decorated cookies, cupcakes, brownies, and petit fours in festive Valentine’s colors. For something extra indulgent, try the Petite Chocolate Praline Heart with rich chocolate mousse and ganache, the Marzipan Fruit Heart layered with strawberry buttercream and glazed fruit, or a pound of hand-dipped chocolate strawberries. They also feature heart-shaped cakes like the classic Red Velvet Heart Cake with cream cheese icing, Yellow and Chocolate Heart Cakes with buttercream or fudge, the decadent Chocolate Leaf Heart Cake and Chocolate Mousse Heart Cake, and a Strawberry Shortcake Heart topped with whipped cream and fresh berries. To round out the holiday selection, Bennison’s offers a variety of heart-shaped cookies — from tea cookies and sugar cookies to conversation heart cookies with fun messages — perfect for sharing or gifting.

Order Online

Fat Tuesday

Bennison’s Bakery is celebrating Valentine’s Day with a delightful selection of holiday-themed sweets and treats available for pre-order or in-store pickup from January 17th through February 20th. Whether you’re looking to surprise a sweetheart or share something special with friends and family, the bakery offers an array of heart-inspired creations, including beautifully decorated cookies, cupcakes, brownies, and petit fours in festive Valentine’s colors. For something extra indulgent, try the Petite Chocolate Praline Heart with rich chocolate mousse and ganache, the Marzipan Fruit Heart layered with strawberry buttercream and glazed fruit, or a pound of hand-dipped chocolate strawberries. They also feature heart-shaped cakes like the classic Red Velvet Heart Cake with cream cheese icing, Yellow and Chocolate Heart Cakes with buttercream or fudge, the decadent Chocolate Leaf Heart Cake and Chocolate Mousse Heart Cake, and a Strawberry Shortcake Heart topped with whipped cream and fresh berries. To round out the holiday selection, Bennison’s offers a variety of heart-shaped cookies — from tea cookies and sugar cookies to conversation heart cookies with fun messages — perfect for sharing or gifting.

Order Online

Location

1000 Davis St.
Evanston, IL 60201

Get Directions

Store Hours 

Mon - Fri: 7am to 6pm
Saturday: 7am to 5pm
Sunday: 7am to 4pm

Order Online
Mail Order

Contact Us

847-328-9434


bennisonsbakery@gmail.com

Join Our Team

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Copyright 1938