• About
    • Our Story
    • Coupe du Monde Award
    • Join Our Team
  • Bakery Items
    • Bakery Items
    • Behind The Scenes
  • Holidays & Specials
    • St. Joseph’s Day
    • Easter
    • Passover
  • Order Online
    • Order for Pickup
    • Mail Order
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Coupe du Monde Award
    • Join Our Team
  • Bakery Items
    • Bakery Items
    • Behind The Scenes
  • Holidays & Specials
    • St. Joseph’s Day
    • Easter
    • Passover
  • Order Online
    • Order for Pickup
    • Mail Order

Halloween

Halloween

Looking for some terrifyingly good treats for Halloween? Bennison's has you covered!

We'll be fully stocked with special treats until October 31st.

No tricks, we promise!

Order Online Now

Or Call 847-328-9434

Treats

Caramel Apple Macaron

Traditional french macaron, filled with our delicious caramel filling with an apple butter center.

Order Online

Taffy Apple Cheese Slice

Our flaky pastry crust, filled with a layer of sweet cream cheese layered with apple pie filling, dark crumb topping toped with caramel.

Order Online
Picture of pumpkin cream cheese galette

Pumpkin Cheese Slice

Our flaky pastry crust, filled with a layer of sweet cream cheese layered with our famous pumpkin pie

Order Online

Petit Fours

Raspberry filled white cake, dipped in white chocolate coating, then decorated with an edible sugar Halloween charm.

Order Online
Picture of ghost and pumpkin decorated cookies

Ghost & Pumpkin Cookies

Our classic butter cookie covered in white chocolate, with chocolate icing decoration.

Ghost Cookie
Pumpkin Cookie
Picture of pumpkin cream cheese galette

Pumpkin Cream Cheese Galette

Our flaky pastry crust, filled with a layer of sweet cream cheese then layered with our famous pumpkin pie and topped with a delicate chocolate curl and pumpkin spice macaron.

Order Online

Cakes

Pumpkin Spice Cake

In 7 or 8 inch sizes, pumpkin spiced cake layers topped with our delicious cream cheese frosting.

Order Online
Picture of cake with halloween pumpkin design on top

Pumpkin Cakes

Friendly or spooky, it's your choice! Made of either chocolate or yellow cake, with buttercream icing and chocolate shape faces, this cake will look great on your Halloween party table.

Order Online
Picture of cake with skull design on top

Skull Cakes

Similar to our Pumpkin Cakes, the Skull Cakes are also made of either chocolate or yellow cake, with buttercream icing and chocolate shape faces.

Order Online

Cupcakes

Picture of ghost cupcakes

Ghost Cupcakes

Chocolate or yellow cake with buttercream icing, you'll definitely say "Boo!" when they're all gone.

Order Online

Mummy Cupcakes

Chocolate or yellow cake with buttercream icing, you'll definitely say "Boo!" when they're all gone.

Order Online
Picture of ghost cupcakes

Halloween Cupcakes

Chocolate or yellow cake with buttercream icing, you'll definitely say "Boo!" when they're all gone.

Order Online

Donuts

Apple Cider

Only available until thanksgiving, our famously delicious glazed apple cider donuts, get them before they are gone!

Order Online

Pumpkin

Only available from Labor Day to Christmas Day, known to cause fights when there's only one left on the shelf, our Pumpkin Cake Donuts will disappear as fast as we can put them in the store.

Order Online

Getting Hungry? Visit the Online Shop to Order for Pickup!

Order online and your items will be put aside and ready for quick and easy pickup.

Order Online

Location

1000 Davis St.
Evanston, IL 60201

Get Directions

Hours

Mon - Fri: 7am to 6pm
Saturday: 7am to 5pm
Sunday: 7am to 4pm

Order Online
Mail Order

Contact Us

847-328-9434


[email protected]

Join Our Team

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Copyright 1938