• About
    • Our Story
    • Coupe du Monde Award
    • Join Our Team
  • Bakery Items
    • Bakery Items
    • Behind The Scenes
  • Farmer’s Markets
  • Holidays & Specials
    • Mother’s Day
  • Order Online
    • Order for Pickup
    • From Our Bakery To Your Door
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Coupe du Monde Award
    • Join Our Team
  • Bakery Items
    • Bakery Items
    • Behind The Scenes
  • Farmer’s Markets
  • Holidays & Specials
    • Mother’s Day
  • Order Online
    • Order for Pickup
    • From Our Bakery To Your Door

Valentine's Day

Need something sweet for your sweetie?

We have cookies, cakes, petit fors, brownies, cupcakes and more all decorated in Valentine's colors. Try one of our cherry marzipan tarts, or take home a dozen chocolate-dipped strawberries, you're guaranteed to make someone smile.

Available for pre orders and in store from Feb 1st to the 14th

Order Online

Or Call 847-328-9434

Treats

Petite Chocolate Praline Heart

A base of crunchy praline, then two layers of chocolate cake filled with rich chocolate mousse that we pour with chocolate ganache. Topped with a heart-shaped macaron and delicate white chocolate lace.

Order Online
Picture of marzipan fruit tart

Marzipan Fruit Heart

Two layers of sponge cake filled with strawberry buttercream, wrapped in chocolate-dipped marzipan then filled with glazed strawberries or cherries.

Order Online

Chocolate Dipped Strawberries

1 pound of fresh strawberries, hand dipped in chocolate.

Order Online

Cupcakes

Our regular chocolate or yellow cake, iced with buttercream or fudge, topped with seasonal sprinkles and a decorative pick.

Order Online

Valentine's Petit Fours

Soft yellow cake layered with with raspberry jam then coated in white chocolate, Bennison's petit fours are perfectly sweet for the holiday.

Order Online

Cheesecake Heart

Heart Shaped New York style cheesecake, topped with fresh strawberries.

Order Online

Cakes

Red Velvet Heart Cake

Red velvet cake, covered with sweet cream cheese icing and decorated with either roses or red gel scrollwork.

Order Online

Yellow Heart Cake

Two layers yellow cake, filled and iced with buttercream or fudge icing, decorated with sprinkles and roses

Order Online

Chocolate Heart Cake

Two layers devil's food cake, filled and iced with buttercream or fudge icing, decorated with sprinkles and roses

Order Online

Chocolate Leaf Heart Cake

Three layers of chocolate cake, two layers of chocolate mousse filling. The entire cake is covered in dark chocolate, then surrounded with chocolate pieces.

Order Online

Chocolate Mousse Heart Cake

Two layers of chocolate cake filled and topped with freshly handmade chocolate mousse cream. Decorated with chocolate curls and whipped cream rosettes.

Order Online

Strawberry Shortcake Heart

Yellow shortcake covered with mountains of whipped cream and a pile of sweet strawberries.

Order Online

Cookies

Tea Cookies

Our tea cookies are sure to make someone's day. A variety of heart shaped cookies, sold by the pound.

Order Online

Sugar Cookies

Our delicious sugar cookie, cut in a heart shape and topped with red sanding sugar before baking.

Order Online

Heart Cookie

Our buttery sugar cookie, iced with pink chocolate candy coating and topped with red, white and pink sprinkles

Order Online

Conversation Heart Cookies

Large heat shaped sugar cookies iced and inscribed with fun frases

Order Online

Getting Hungry? Visit the Online Shop to Order for Pickup!

Order online and your items will be put aside and ready for quick and easy pickup.

Order Online

Location

1000 Davis St.
Evanston, IL 60201

Get Directions

Hours

Mon - Fri: 7am to 6pm
Saturday: 7am to 5pm
Sunday: 7am to 4pm

Order Online
Mail Order

Contact Us

847-328-9434


bennisonsbakery@gmail.com

Join Our Team

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Copyright 2025