• About
    • Our Story
    • Coupe du Monde Award
    • Join Our Team
  • Bakery Items
    • Bakery Items
    • Behind The Scenes
  • Farmer’s Markets
  • Holidays & Specials
    • Mother’s Day
  • Order Online
    • Order for Pickup
    • From Our Bakery To Your Door
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Coupe du Monde Award
    • Join Our Team
  • Bakery Items
    • Bakery Items
    • Behind The Scenes
  • Farmer’s Markets
  • Holidays & Specials
    • Mother’s Day
  • Order Online
    • Order for Pickup
    • From Our Bakery To Your Door

Custom Cupcakes

Custom Cupcakes

They're small, they're sweet, they fit right in your hand, they're perfect for those times when you want cake but not too much cake.

From simple to fancy, there's a right cupcake for any time!

Order Online

Or Call 847-328-9434

Picture of iced cupcakes

Current Menu

Picture of iced cupcakes

Iced Cupcakes

Our classic iced cupcake. A 2 inch wide cupcake in either yellow or chocolate that is frosted with butter cream or our fudge icing. Usually topped with sprinkles, or whatever is appropriate for the season. If you need more than a dozen though, it's best to call and order ahead. Every color of sprinkle is available for special orders, and we also have "Happy Birthday!" picks.

Picture of cupcakes decorated with flowers

Flower Power Cupcakes

The same 2 inch chocolate or yellow cake as our regular iced cupcakes, but dressed up with floral decoration. Our Flower Power Cupcakes are available in any color you'd like. 

Available in the store only in Spring and Summer, but still available to order the rest of the year with 48 hours notice.

Picture of pupcake

Pupcakes

Our Pupcakes are topped with chocolate butter cream, then decorated with fudge and buttercream icing.

Available every day in the store, but for larger amounts it's still best to call ahead and order.

Picture of carrot cake cupcake

Carrot Cake Cupcake

A 3 inch cupcake version of our carrot cake. This one is topped just with sweetend cream cheese icing, then decorated with a butter cream carrot. Enough for two people, but way too good to share, carrot cake cupcakes are in the store every day.

Picture of red velvet cupcake

Red Velvet Cupcake

No matter how many we make, we always sell out. A 3 inch moist, rich red velvet cake topped with sweet cream cheese icing and red velvet cake crumbs. We put a new batch in the store every day, and they're always gone by closing, so come early or call ahead and order one (or a dozen).

Custom Decorated Cupcakes

Available by special order only, if you can think it up chances are our decorator can put it on a cupcake! Your choice of either our 2 or 3 inch cupcake, in chocolate, yellow, carrot or red velvet flavors. A minimum of 48 hours advance notice is required, and pricing is based on cupcake size and complexity of decoration.

To make sure that our decorator understands exactly what you'd like, please be specific!

Send us pictures, drawings, internet links, anything you think will help us create exactly the cupcakes you want.

Getting Hungry? Visit the Online Shop to Order for Pickup!

Order online and your items will be put aside and ready for quick and easy pickup.

Order Online

Location

1000 Davis St.
Evanston, IL 60201

Get Directions

Hours

Mon - Fri: 7am to 6pm
Saturday: 7am to 5pm
Sunday: 7am to 4pm

Order Online
Mail Order

Contact Us

847-328-9434


bennisonsbakery@gmail.com

Join Our Team

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Copyright 1938