• About
    • Our Story
    • Coupe du Monde Award
    • Join Our Team
  • Bakery Items
    • Bakery Items
    • Behind The Scenes
  • Farmer’s Markets
  • Holidays & Specials
    • Mother’s Day
  • Order Online
    • Order for Pickup
    • From Our Bakery To Your Door
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Coupe du Monde Award
    • Join Our Team
  • Bakery Items
    • Bakery Items
    • Behind The Scenes
  • Farmer’s Markets
  • Holidays & Specials
    • Mother’s Day
  • Order Online
    • Order for Pickup
    • From Our Bakery To Your Door

New Year's

New Year's 2025

We will be open on New Years Eve Tuesday, December 31st from 7 AM to 1 PM.

We will be closed on Wednesday, January 1st & Thursday, January 2nd.

Order Online Now

Or Call 847-328-9434

Galette Des Rois

Each year we offer Pithivier (or Galette des Rois). Layers of puff pastry filled with almond frangipane (a sweet almond paste), glazed with sugar and topped with a crown. Each Pithivier is baked with a tiny baby trinket inside, and tradition states that whoever finds the baby in their slice is supposed to bring the Pithivier the next year.

Order Online

Croquembouche

A truly decadent Christmas tradition. The Croquenbouche, which means "crunch in the mouth" in French, is made from flaky profiteroles filled with Grand Marnier pastry cream, stacked using pure caramel as a "glue", then draped with delicate strings of sugar. Almost too pretty to eat, the Croquenbouche is perfect as both a centerpiece and a dessert. 

Order Online

Prices start at $83 for the 28 profiterole Croquembouche, and go up by $3 per additional profiterole, to any size you'd like, call the bakery to order a custom size.

Buche de Noel (Yule Log)

Our most popular Christmas item, once featured in North Shore Magazine. A chocolate sponge roulade filled with chocolate praline mousse and iced with our homemade fudge icing, finished with St. Nick and meringue mushrooms.

Large Yule Log
Picture of christmas stollen

Weihnachtsstollen

An all butter German Christmas treat loaded with rum soaked raisins, lemon and orange peel, cracked almonds and filled with marzipan. After baking it's coated with melted butter and rolled in vanilla sugar. Striving to create the most authentic Weihnachtsstollen possible, we use a spice blend from an artisan spice mill in Darmstadt, Germany. The powdered sugar we dust them with comes from Volklingen, Germany. Even the pans our Stollen is baked in are German, made in Miedelsbach.

Order Online

New Years Cookies

Order Online

New Years Petit Fors

Order Online

Champagne Macaron

Order Online

New Years Cupcakes

Order Online
Picture of french silk pie with chocolate on top

 

French Silk Pie

Order Online

Dinner Rolls

Seeded Knot & Plain Round
Traditional rich egg dough. Knots are topped with either poppy or sesame seeds. They are bagged 4 plain and 4 of each seed. The plain round are perfect for mini turkey sandwiches.

Rustic Grain
We blend organic rye and whole wheat flours, sesame seeds, flax seeds, millet, oatmeal & cracked rye. We bake it in a “squareish” shape with a floury outside.

Parkerhouse Rolls
Rich egg dough sweetened with honey and loaded with butter.

Order Online

Getting Hungry? Visit the Online Shop to Order for Pickup!

Order online and your items will be put aside and ready for quick and easy pickup.

Order Online

Location

1000 Davis St.
Evanston, IL 60201

Get Directions

Hours

Mon - Fri: 7am to 6pm
Saturday: 7am to 5pm
Sunday: 7am to 4pm

Order Online
Mail Order

Contact Us

847-328-9434


bennisonsbakery@gmail.com

Join Our Team

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Copyright 1938